Data Dividends Integration
Proposal to add "Data Dividends" as a component of Layer 3 (Collective Ownership) in the Pyramid of Prosperity. This would establish a mechanism for citizens to receive compensation for the use of their personal data by corporations.
High Priority
Due: Feb 3, 2026
Evaluation Checklist
Problem Statement Clear
The proposal clearly articulates the problem being solved
Solution Well-Defined
The proposed solution is specific and actionable
Evidence Provided
Claims are supported by research, data, or real-world examples
Alternatives Considered
The proposal discusses why alternatives were rejected
Consequences Addressed
Both positive and negative consequences are documented
Principle Alignment Assessment
Human Agency First
Evidence Over Ideology
Incremental Transition
Global Applicability
Impact Assessment
Scope
Global
Complexity
Medium
Reversibility
High
Dependencies
3
Community Consensus
78% Agreement
Approve (62%)
Changes (16%)
Reject (7%)
Pending (15%)
47
Approvals
12
Changes
5
Rejections
Discussion 47 comments
I strongly support this proposal. Data dividends align well with our principle of collective ownership. The main question is implementation — how do we ensure fair valuation of data contributions across different demographics?
The evidence section could be stronger. Can we reference the existing data dividend pilots in California and the EU's digital dividend discussions? This would help establish credibility.